Katie McCool as Marian Paroo and Rob Frankel as Harold Hill in Methacton Community Theater's production of THE MUSIC MAN.

The Music Is Super in Methacton Community Theater’s MUSIC MAN

Posted by

Cliff Reese as Ewart Dunlop, Rob Frankel as Harold Hill, Jude Adams as Marcellus Washburn and Ellen Hromada as Mrs. Squires plus other residents of River City in Methacton Community Theater’s THE MUSIC MAN.

Meredith Willson’s THE MUSIC MAN is a natural pick for community theater groups.  There is a plethora of very singable songs with just enough difficulty to make them a little work.  It has a variety of character parts to play, of all ages.  And it has the possibility of using a lot of children, which usually means a lot of tickets get sold.  And, most of all, it’s a fun show to do and to watch.

Methacton Community Theater’s production involves 53 people on stage and many more backstage.  It was an enjoyable evening.

Conductor and Music Director Alex Cifelli led a 17 piece orchestra that was several cuts above what I have heard in most community theater.  Bravo, Mr. Cifelli!

As Marian (the librarian) Paroo, Kate McCool sang and acted very well.   She has a strong soprano and was adept at holding the notes as they were written.   The evening’s Harold Hill was Rob Frankel.   He had the right moves and understood the con man part.  The transition from con man to man in love, although sparsely written, was rushed and not convincing.   It all has to happen in the double reprise at the end of Act Two.  Frankel does the rest so well that, I’m sure he can make that work, too.

Jude Adams puts in a welcome appearance as Marcellus Washburn.  He is delightful whenever he’s onstage.  Michael Sherman, Cliff Reese, Mark Dobbins, and Bill Shimer comprise the School Board made over into a barbershop quartet.  It’s the most difficult harmony in THE MUSIC MAN.  They looked like they were having fun and added to the merriment.

David Kriebel made Charlie Cowell, the anvil salesman, the perfect picture of what we think of as the well-known Traveling Salesman.  There were terrific performances from Michelle Quigley as the Mayor’s wife, Danny Habboush as Winthrop Paroo, Zoe Muller as Zaneeta Shinn, and Nick Capriotti as Tommy Dijilas.

Lynn Corfield was a warm Mrs. Paroo although her Irish accent wandered about here and there.  I’d like to see more bluster and pomposity from David Moyer as Mayor Shinn. He handles the major part of the humor in the piece.

Katie McCool as Marian Paroo and Rob Frankel as Harold Hill.

Director Ken Brown did his usual fine job of moving a huge number of people around.  He kept the tempo up and sprightly.  The Rock Island number from the men in the cast got things going in the right way.  As Choreographer, Lauren McGinnis did a super job on the “Marian the Librarian” and the “Shipoopi” numbers.

The scenery was excellent as were the costumes and lighting.  The air conditioning in the Middle school auditorium was more than adequate.   Take a sweater with you when you go. Bring the Family.   You’ll enjoy THE MUSIC MAN.

Music and Lyrics by Meredith Willson
Book by Meredith Willson and Frank Lacey
Directed by Ken Brown
Methacton Community Theater
Perkiomen Middle School
100 Kagey Road
Collegeville, PA 19426

The following two tabs change content below.
Arnie Finkel

Arnie Finkel

Arnie has been directing and conducting Musical Theater for over 50 years. He has a BS in Communications for Radio and Television Production from Temple University. As a Theater Minor, Arnie was privileged to work under Pop Randall. Arnie was Station Manager of WRTI, did news editing at WFIL for Gunnar Back and John Roberts, and did a stint as film editor there. His Musical training started when, at 8 years of age he studied percussion under Benjamin Podemsky, the head of the percussion section of the Philadelphia Orchestra. Since directing and conducting his first show at 17 (Finian’s Rainbow) Arnie has done close to 100 Music Theater productions. He and his lovely wife of 52 years, Lorri, teach Music Theater at Life Long Learn for Temple University.


  1. Mary Wright says:

    I enjoyed the Saturday matinee. Espically when my grandson lost his shoe and had to find it.

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The poster sent us ‘0 which is not a hashcash value.

  2. Barbara Fithett says:

    Arnie, you must have seen an entirely different production than the one I saw. Rob Frankel playing Harold Hill gave the best performance I have ever seen in Community Theater in that role. He took command of the stage and you felt the entire time he was Robert Preston transformed to our local stage. You missed your mark on this review completely. He was both charming and believable. Lynn Corfield as Widow Paroo was terrific in her role and her accent was right on the mark.

Leave a Reply