Show: I SUSPECT
Theater: First Avenue Playhouse
Theater Website: https://firstavenueplayhouse.com/
Show runs: 09/11/2026 to 09/26/2026
I, SUSPECT tells the story of the murder of news anchor Cyrus Telyn and the challenge for the two detectives assigned to the case when every one of their suspects claims to be guilty. Whilst navigating the antics of an obnoxiously perky narrator, a slew of Harry Potter references and the suspects’ increasingly-wild attempts to prove their own guilt, the only way the detectives are going to solve this case is by breaking the lies apart one-by-one. Hopefully by the end, they’ll have the answer to the big question: Who Didn’t Dunnit.
First Avenue Playhouse
A Dessert Theatre
September 2026
Director: Tara London
Show Times & Dates:
$30 | 7:30 PM Friday & Saturday, September 11th–26th
$30 | 2:30 PM Sunday Matinee, September 13th & 20th
Seniors or Students: $25 Friday & Sunday
Ticket Details:
Play admission includes a slice of gourmet cake, coffee, & soda.
Venue Location:
123 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07712
Box Office: 732-291-7552
Theater Address: 123 First Avenue Atla,ntic Highlands, New Jersey 07712 (Map It)
Theater Phone: (732) 291-7552
Price: $30/$25
Purchase tickets online: https://firstavenueplayhouse.com/
